BlackBerry Curve vs. HTC Mogul
November 21st, 2008Well, it has been almost two months since we got the BlackBerries. I’ve been using my BlackBerry pretty much exclusively since I got it activated, with a couple of exceptions.
See, initially I had planned on using a Windows Mobile-based phone, like the HTC Mogul or the brand-new Touch Pro. In fact, after playing with a Mogul a few times at a couple different Sprint kiosks in the mall, I was ready to get one of those. So ready, in fact, that I actually bought one off of eBay, anticipating that I would sell my like-new BlackBerry and move to the Mogul.
On Tuesday night, I decided to activate my Mogul — that is, more my phone number to it — and try it out. I immediately found myself missing the BlackBerry, and by Wednesday afternoon, my BB Curve was back online, and my Mogul was headed back for eBay.
Honestly, I find myself kind of shocked to have sided with the BlackBerry. The last few months I was with Verizon, I had a Palm Treo 700wx, which runs Windows Mobile. I was sure that I would want to use something with WM. Besides, the BlackBerries just seemed… weird. The interface is different. The way they handle e-mail is different. The browser is different.
So what happened? Why did I ditch the Mogul so quickly?
Simply put, I just missed the BlackBerry! I missed most everything about it — its size, its ease of use, its keyboard, its applications, its functionality as a phone, the cohesiveness of everything.
The Mogul, I thought, was going to be the ideal phone for me. It runs Windows Mobile, and it has a nice touch screen, a large slide-out keyboard, and built-in wireless infrared, along with Bluetooth. It has everything! Almost.
In reality, the Mogul just couldn’t compare to the Curve. Ease of use, the Curve won hands-down, and I think the best way to explain why is to say this: The Mogul appears to be a miniature computer first, a cell phone second. While the idea of a pocket-sized computer is extremely appealing, the device just seems kind of sluggish overall. And the phone aspect of it just doesn’t seem that great.
The slide-out keyboard on the Mogul, which I thought was kind of cool and a very clever design, ended up being somewhat of a pain to use. The keyboard itself seems to work very well, but it’s that sliding that gets to be bothersome. Plus, the Mogul is not very easy to use one-handed when it’s open; you pretty much need to be holding it with both hands while the keyboard is out.
To its credit, the Mogul has built-in wireless, which is a nice plus. Also, it does a real good job of streaming audio and video from my desktop computer. I can actually watch live TV on there if I wanted to, and it looks very good!
Another huge selling point for the Mogul, or any Windows Mobile device, was the ability to be able to use my remote-control software in order to log in to any computer and control it remotely — on the Mogul itself!
This actually worked really, really well, and despite the small screen size, I think it could be practical, particularly in those times where I’m away from the house (and without my laptop), and somebody needs some quick remote help.
The third main advantage for the Mogul, as I could see it, was its auto-complete feature with text. Basically, when you’re typing, a little drop-down menu will appear that suggests different words. So if you typed “def,” it may suggest “definitely,” and it then saves you quite a few keystrokes when you select the word. Also, what was nice is the auto-complete would learn new words. So before long, it recognized “Arndt,” and would start to suggest it.
Back to the BlackBerry. Normally, I’m not a huge fan of a turnkey approach for gadgets or computers. I love to customize, to tweak, to extend whatever it is I’m using. So I came into the world of BlackBerry dreading that perceived loss of functionality or extensibility.
Well, what I have quickly learned is that sometimes it’s a good thing to have someone else do it for you. I’m amazed at just how well-done the BlackBerry is. Everything fuses together so well, and it really is the ultimate e-mail/messaging device!
In addition to e-mail and text-messaging, they have chat clients for AIM, Yahoo, Google Talk, and the BlackBerry Messenger, which is just a great little chat program for BB users. Also, there are MySpace and Facebook applications, which make accessing your account a lot easier.
On top of all of that, there are alerts for each of those programs, and you can customize what happens when, say, you receive an alert on Facebook, or if you have a message on Google Talk.
Also, the way the Curve handles e-mail is unique but very nice! Basically, instead of your device having to check e-mail every five or 10 minutes, the BlackBerry service will do the work for you, and will just send you the messages the instant they arrive. Pretty nice!
I’m not crazy about the way the Curve deals with streaming audio and video, though. For some reason, it’s just really bad at it; I can’t really use it to log in and watch TV. Not that that’s a big issue, really, but it is a really cool feature to have available.
So while the Curve isn’t perfect, I really am blown away by how well it works and by how much I just like it!! The BlackBerry Messenger program is becoming one of my favorites, because all of the guys in the family can chat live on it. In fact, yesterday, Jude, John, and I had a three-way chat going on, as we were trying to figure out some last-minute details on covering depositions. It’s perfect for times where you can’t just make a phone call.
I’m still really surprised in myself, that I’m so quickly giving up on the idea of the Mogul. But, honestly, this BlackBerry is just such a nice little device, so tightly-integrated and VERY wisely put together. I think I’m in love!
